INTRODUCTION
At this turn of millennia the life of humanity is becoming increasingly
global and for a number of important reasons. Physically, we have developed the
capacity to transform the environment of the entire earth -- though often for
the worse, rather than the better. Indeed, we now have even the nuclear
capability to destroy broad species, including humankind as a whole.
Economically, with the end of the Cold War the world
is no longer divided between two world systems, but now constitutes one
economy so that collapse at any point has a ripple effect throughout.
Politically, the needs of a particular nation, through alliances and
international systems can have determinative impact upon the lives of people
everywhere. Culturally, through the communication media the same pervasive power
is at work.
Is the overall effect good or bad? Both can be argued -- and indeed were
deeply explored at a conference entitled "Philosophical Challenges and
Opportunities of Globalization." This was held in Boston on the occasion of
The World Congress of Philosophy and was co-sponsored by The International
Society for Metaphysics, The World Union of Catholic Philosophical Societies,
The Council for Research in Values and Philosophy and Boston College.
This conference responded to the fact that rationalism had long
considered philosophy to be an individual endeavor conducted abstractly in the
privacy of a closed study or within the confines of a certain national spirit.
In certain respects philosophy will retain something of this. But, in the face
of globalization understood culturally as well as economically, philosophy must
deepen human self-understanding corporately through joint phenomenological
reflection and interchange upon the conscious human experiences of all peoples.
The conference brought together philosophers from all parts of the world for
just such concentrated discussion and critical evaluation of globalization
itself.
Globalization is a new phenomenon with economic, political and
cultural-philosophical dimensions. Economically, it is in interlocking
supra-national system with power to effect the development and underdevelopment
of the different parts of the world, rich as well as poor. As a system, it has
certain overarching tendencies in relation to such higher human interests and
values as personal identity, social justice, national sovereignty and the
various conceptions of cultural and religious life. It can marginalize not only
people in various parts of the world, but also things, social as well as
individual, which are valued by people as human beings.
Politically, it constitutes a system of interchange of power with which
peoples in all parts of the world must contend, each in their own ways, in order
democratically to maintain their human identities in cooperation with others.
Culturally, globalization allows a new openness of the human spirit which
may present opportunity as well as challenge. In retrospect, the last millennium
could be interpreted as a great project of human reason, beginning from the high
middle ages with the reintroduction of the Aristotelian corpus and the great Summas.
This focus upon reason was radicalized in the Enlightenment with many undoubted
good effects enabling the world to support a burgeoning population through
inventions ranging from nutrition, to communication, to law. But this
radicalization has remained largely Euro-centric in its thinking, marginalizing
other forms of thought and culture and leaving them far from liberated.
Soon after Descartes, J.B. Vico noted that so radical and exclusive a
focus upon reason in the laboratory of clear and distinct ideas would not allow
for the development of other, properly human dimensions of human awareness, but
instead would generate brutes -- intellectual brutes, but brutes nonetheless.
Recently, especially with the collapse of the cold war, we have become more
sensitive to the limitations of the abstractive power of this Euro-centric
technical reason which channeled social understanding toward the extremes of
individualism and communism. Looking back, there appears now to be a fairly
universal consensus that we do not want to repeat the last century with its
world wars, hot and cold; its pogroms, holocausts and mass -- even atomic --
bombings; and its economic and cultural exploitation.
This philosophical critique now extends across the entire modern project
from left to right so that it is common to refer to present times as postmodern,
if not post-European. But as life cannot be built upon skepticism, this opens a
radically new opportunity, namely to regain and reintegrate other dimensions of
reason, deeper reaches of the human personality and a broader range of
sensibilities into more complete senses of life, diverse cultures, minorities,
women and the environment. Whereas "postmodern" bespeaks criticism of
what preceded, "globalization" points forward to a new philosophical
agenda, namely, both horizontally to broaden awareness to include all peoples
and cultures, and vertically to deepen to the metaphysical and religious
dimensions of meaning and values where humanity dwells in the Spirit.
At the turn of the millennia, therefore, this conference explored the
expansion of this sphere in which we live, and move, and have our being. This
was an exercise of human responsibility for the reflective dimension of civil
society. Among others the topics implied in this theme included a critical
appreciation of reason and of the new reaches of human awareness; the
implications of cultural awareness for the enrichment and extension of
philosophy; and the responsibility of philosophy in the evolution from
conflictual to peaceful human interchange -- not only economic and political,
but especially social, cultural and religious.
Hence the structure of the investigation of globalization in the volume
begins with Part I on "Economic and Political Globalization," proceeds
to Part II on "Culture and Globalization," and concludes with Part III
on "Globalization and Metaphysics, Ethics and Religion."
Part I on "Economic and Political Globalization" contains a
variety of contrasting views. It begins with a set of critiques of economic
globalization. Some are quite strong; together they reflect views from both
North and South.
Chapter I by Oliva Blanchette, "Globalization or Humanization: A
Question of Priorities in Human Development," presents a view of the
economic order as oligarchic and exploitive of the poor.
Chapter II by Pablo Lopez Lopez, "Old and New Globalization,"
is equally strong in its critique of globalization as an imposition of the
ideology of liberal capitalism upon other parts of the world. In this he
presents a vigorous critique of Chapter V below by Gary Madison.
Chapter III by Fredrico Jose Alvarez, "The Deconstruction of the
Antilles," describes what the above means concretely, using the example of
his own Dominican Republic in the Caribbean.
Chapter IV by Chibueze C. Udeani, "African Cultural Identity in the
Context of Globalization: Opportunities and Dangers," confirms the above by
describing the effects of this process upon Africa, beginning from the period of
political colonization and continuing today by economic means.
The above critical stance is strongly questioned by the positive
description of globalization presented in Chapter V by Gary Madison
"Globalization: Challenges and Opportunities." He presents
globalization not as a process of suppression of differences and of peoples, but
as opening new possibilities -- he would think, the only possibilities -- for
them to thrive. This explains why participation in the global economic system is
so ardently, if begrudgingly sought.
Chapter VI by Mervyn Fernando, "Violence and the Rising Tide of
Globalization: A Teilhardian Perspective," would attempt to understand the
violence which accompanies this process as a harsh, but passing phase of a
generally progressive evolution in terms of the evolutionary of Teilhard de
Chardin.
Finally Chapter VII by Nguyen Trong Chuan, "Globalization:
Opportunities and Challenges," presents an overview of globalization in its
benefits and burdens, which bridges from Part I to Part II.
Part II on "Cultural Globalization" focuses on the deeper
cultural issues of globalization. It is true that globalization is shaped by
issues of environment, economy and politics. But beneath these, culture operates
at a deeper level to shape the responses of peoples to these challenges.
Chapter VIII by Tomonobu Imamichi, "Contraries and Compatibilities
in a Time of Cultural Globalization," looks with great wisdom and insight
into the character of the cultural interaction entailed by globalization or even
the heart of globalization as the profound human phenomenon of our times.
Chapter IX by Vincent Shen, "Construction of a Meaningful World in I
Ching," looks deeply into the roots of Chinese culture to find
potential resources for this work, and even for the possibilities for developing
virtual worlds in our future.
Chapter X by R. Balasubramamian, "Traditional Cultural and
Modernization," views this from the perspective of classical Hindu thought
and the potentialities of Indian cultures for globalization.
If this is to be a humane and creative process realized by humanity
rather than imposed thereupon by the blind hand of the market and the profit
motive or by the harsh hand of politics grasping for power, then it is necessary
to see how the spirit works deeply. The following three chapters take up this
challenge.
Chapter XI by Jean Ladrière, "The Aesthetic Dimension of
Science," in a veritable tour de force faces this on the least
promising terrain by looking deeply into science as mathematical to discern even
there the role of the aesthetic. On a quite different level this path is
followed in Chapter XII by Ghislaine Florival, "Reconstruction of the
Subject in View of Contemporary Globalization," where she shows the role of
the subject in the contemporary process of globalization, especially as this
constitutes a human and hence ethical work. Chapter XIII by Nguyen Van Huyen,
"Art and Its Suggestion to Man's Creative Potential," extends this to
the aesthetic order.
Chapter XIV by A.T. Dalfovo, "From Global Interests to Cultural
Values," looks at this from an African perspective and follows the
deepening of insight from global economic interests to the progressive evolution
of cultural values.
Chapter XV by Kirti Buchua, "Creation of New Philosophy in the Age
of the Global Village," discusses how globalization implies a new
approaches to the work of philosophizing itself in order not to suppress or
ignore the culture of peoples, but to draw upon them.
Finally, Part III, "Globalization and Metaphysics, Ethics and
Religion," takes the discussions deeper still to the level of metaphysics
and religion. Samuel Huntington in his now famous Clash of Civilizations
notes that each great civilization is founded upon a great religion and
conversely that each great religion (except Buddhism) has generated a
civilization. If there is truth to this analysis then understanding the
challenges and opportunities of globalization requires a deeper inspection of
the roots of the cultures involved.
Chapter XVI by Margaret Chatterjee, "Religion and Social
Harmony," begins this search by pointing out a new and perhaps paradoxical
phenomenon in this regard. While the great religions were universal in intent
they were strongly transcendent in their orientation to a life above and beyond
this globe. Now the horizon shifts so that the emphasis is rather imminent than
transcendent, and is experienced phenomenologically as a matter of ultimate
concern.
Chapter XVII by Mihaela Pop, "The Promethean Man: Eastward or
Westward?," suggests another alternative, namely, that of those who,
turning away from the transcendent, fall into the secular humanism of the modern
West.
Chapter XVIII by Duan Dezhi, "On the History, Theoretical
Difficulties and Prospects of Subjectivity in Western Theory," combats this
danger of all becoming merely a matter of human subjectivity in which the
reality of the divine as more than human would disappear.
Chapter XIX by Tran Van Doan, "Maritain's Concept of Integral
Humanism," attempts to bridge this divide by pointing to a missing link in
Maritain's integral humanism. This sees human transcendence as a deification
through the Incarnation of Christ as God-man, but it does not carry out the
parallel reasoning to show how the human, though not divine, is essentially
oriented to transcendence.
Chapter XX by Errol E. Harris, "The Problem of Sovereignty in
International Relations," sets globalization in tension with national
sovereignty. In fact we do not now have structures for a simple transfer of
power from nations to supra-national entities. But this may not be so necessary
if life and hence responsibility is conceived in broader terms, along with our
sense of responsibility. This can be especially true to the degree that social
cooperation is included from within and below, rather than being imposed
coercively from without and above.
Chapter XXI by H. Daniel Dei, "Identity and Globalization: The
Metaphysical Question for the 21st Century," carries this line of
argumentation to its culmination by bringing to light the ontological
underpinning of human life. This relates man to God while assuring the
ontological distinction of both. In this way he lays the deep metaphysical
ground for globalization as not suppressing but enhancing persons in their being
and cultural identities.
Chapter XXII by R. Magliola, " Two Models of Trinity -- French Post-Structuralist
versus the Historical Critical: Argued in the Form of a Dialogue," goes
still further to carry the discussion into the life of the Trinity. He does this
in a way that illustrates the potential benefits of globalization. He opens the
issue of the Trinity by a positive use of postmodern thought and then engages
Buddhist thought to enable the human spirit to relate more fully to the
Trinitarian life.
Chapter XXIII by William Sweet, "Globalization, Philosophy and the
Model of Ecumenism," considers globalization as a process lived by people
and illustrates this by the form of dialogue already emerging between religions.
Chapter XXIV by George F. McLean, "Globalization as Diversity in
Unity," draws on the thought of Nicholas of Cusa to model a new way of
thinking, now not in analytic terms of the parts but in synthetic terms of the
whole.
In sum, the volume itself reaches across boundaries and reflects a global
vision, not only through the combined dialectic of the studies, but through the
origin of its authors. In both these ways it opens the way for the exploration
of human comity upon which we enter in the new millennium.